Beyond Compliance: Improving Security Officer Selection Worldwide

Posted by: Dr. Justin D'Arienzo, Psy.D., ABPP

D’Arienzo Psychology · ASSIST 2026

Beyond Compliance: Improving Security Officer Selection Worldwide

Insights from Dr. Justin D’Arienzo’s ASSIST 2026 presentation, drawing on experience involving more than 6,000 armed-security psychological evaluations.

By Dr. Justin D’Arienzo, Psy.D., MSCP, ABPP
Last updated: November 17, 2026

Board-Certified Clinical Psychologist · Former U.S. Navy Psychologist
Licensed Texas Psychologist · Multistate Licensure · PSYPACT Authority

Security companies trust their officers to carry firearms, protect clients, and make decisions under pressure. A completed licensing form answers only part of the hiring question.

Employers also need to know whether the person has the judgment, self-control, reliability, and people skills the assignment requires.

That was the focus of my presentation at the 2026 conference of the Associated Security Services and Investigators of the State of Texas (ASSIST):
“Beyond Compliance: Using the MMPI to Improve Armed Security Officer Selection.”

Although I spoke to a Texas audience, the same question matters to security companies worldwide:
How can organizations turn psychological screening into a meaningful part of personnel selection?

My experience involving more than 6,000 armed-security psychological evaluations shaped the talk. I explained how testing, individual interviews, job demands, and clear employer procedures work together.

Presentation details: View Dr. Justin D’Arienzo’s ASSIST 2026 session on Whova — October 7, 2026, at The Menger Hotel in San Antonio, Texas. Whova may require sign-in.

Dr. Justin D’Arienzo presenting state security guard testing requirements at ASSIST 2026.
Dr. Justin D’Arienzo presents on armed-security psychological screening at ASSIST 2026 in San Antonio, Texas.

What Texas Can Teach Us About Security Officer Selection

In Texas, MMPI testing is part of licensing for commissioned security officers and personal protection officers. That makes the state a useful example of how screening and employer responsibility overlap.

However, meeting a licensing requirement does not tell an employer whether a candidate fits a particular assignment.

This distinction also matters when a company works in several states or countries. For example, hospital security and executive protection involve different demands. Employers need a process that addresses those demands as well as local licensing rules.

Start with the licensing rules. Then ask: What does this job require, and what do we need the evaluation to tell us?

My earlier article,

Armed Security Officer Psychological Screening: 10 Questions Employers Should Ask

explains the traits that matter for armed-security work. In the ASSIST presentation, I focused on how employers can use those ideas.

Putting MMPI Results in Context

The Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory, including the MMPI-3, helps assess psychological functioning. It also provides clues about how a person approached the test.

To make that information useful, a qualified evaluator must consider it alongside the rest of the assessment.

During the presentation, I emphasized a central principle:

“The MMPI is a data source. Evaluation is the integration.”

In practice, I bring several sources together: testing, a separate history and risk questionnaire, an individual interview, and information about the job. When findings need clarification, follow-up is part of that process.

For example, a candidate may have no major clinical elevations on testing. Yet the interview may reveal repeated workplace conflicts and trouble staying calm when challenged. The evaluator needs to explore those concerns and consider how they relate to the job.

A reassuring test profile should not lead an evaluator to overlook other evidence. At the same time, a concern deserves a fair review; it does not automatically mean the person is unsuitable.

Dr. Justin D’Arienzo explaining the MMPI-3 at the ASSIST 2026 conference at The Menger Hotel.
Explaining how the MMPI-3 contributes to an integrated occupational evaluation at The Menger Hotel, October 7, 2026.

Stability and Suitability: Two Different Questions

Psychological stability
concerns psychological difficulties that could interfere with safe and effective performance.

Psychological suitability
concerns whether the individual’s characteristics support the demands of the particular position.

These questions overlap, but they are not interchangeable.

For example, a person may show no major psychological problems but still raise concerns about self-control, teamwork, or judgment. Conversely, past mental-health treatment does not tell us how someone functions today. Each person needs an individual assessment tied to the job.

For security leaders, this means defining what successful performance actually requires.

Examples of assignment-specific psychological demands
Security assignmentDemands to address in the evaluation
Hospital securityDe-escalation, emotional regulation, communication with distressed people
Executive protectionDiscretion, adaptability, situational awareness, judgment under pressure
Critical infrastructureDependability, vigilance, procedural consistency, attention to safety
Retail and public-facing securityRestraint, professional assertiveness, conflict management, communication

These examples help frame the referral. They are not stand-alone hiring criteria or substitutes for a job analysis.

Applying Public-Safety Principles to Private Security

The California Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training provides an established framework for psychological screening in law enforcement. Its

Peace Officer Psychological Screening Manual

addresses the evaluation process and job-related psychological suitability.

During the talk, I explained how private security employers can adapt relevant parts of this approach.

The work begins with the actual security assignment. Private security personnel and sworn police officers can have different responsibilities, authority, training, and operating environments. Those differences matter when choosing assessment methods and interpreting findings.

For instance, the evaluation can address how someone follows procedures, communicates, accepts supervision, and makes decisions. These are behaviors that matter on the job.

What Our Preliminary Security Officer Data Suggest

The presentation also included an exploratory comparison involving
4,619 armed-security applicants from D’Arienzo Psychology’s dataset
and published MMPI-3 police comparison statistics representing 2,036 individuals.

We found estimated statistical differences across several scales. These early findings raise questions about how security applicants compare with other public-safety groups. They also support further research focused on private security.

Understanding the research

However, this was an early internal analysis using rounded published comparison statistics. It does not establish validated norms for security applicants. Nor does it show that one group is safer or justify new hiring cutoffs.

Also, a difference can be statistically significant in a large sample without making much difference in practice.

For employers, research can guide judgment, but each decision still needs to fit the person, the job, and the strength of the evidence.

Three Requirements for a Workable Screening Program

To help employers put this into practice, my presentation and worksheet focused on three priorities.

01 · Validity

Use appropriate assessment methods and connect the evaluation to the job. Integrate testing with interviews, history, and relevant supporting information.

02 · Accountability

First, agree on the purpose of the evaluation and the evaluator’s qualifications. Also decide what to document, who may receive the results, and how reviews will work.

03 · Affordability

Build a process the company can sustain. For example, coordinate scheduling and avoid duplicate work. Choose the scope of testing to fit the reason for the referral.

Better screening does not necessarily require adding more tests. Often, the improvement comes from better information, clearer questions, and stronger coordination between the employer and psychologist.

How to Build a Screening Process

The ASSIST worksheet sets out the following steps:

  1. Establish the referral purpose and appropriate employment stage.
  2. Provide an accurate job description and essential functions.
  3. Complete informed consent, identity verification, and a separate history questionnaire.
  4. Conduct the individual psychological interview and appropriate testing.
  5. Resolve meaningful gaps or conflicting information through follow-up.
  6. Communicate a clear occupational determination to the authorized recipient.
  7. Apply established review and documentation procedures consistently.

For U.S. employers covered by the ADA, medical and disability-related screening must follow the rules applicable to the employment stage. Post-offer examinations require consistency within the same job category; examinations during employment generally require job-relatedness and business necessity. Employers must also protect the confidentiality of medical information. See the

EEOC’s guidance on disability-related inquiries and medical examinations
.

Outside the United States, local employment and privacy laws also matter. Evaluators need the proper professional authority. In addition, the tests and language must fit the people being assessed.

A Message for Security Companies Worldwide

Although this presentation took place in Texas, the challenge reaches much further. Security personnel hold positions of trust wherever they work.

A company can use the same basic principles across its locations. However, the details must fit local laws and working conditions.

In each location, start with a clear job description. Then use suitable assessment methods, qualified judgment, and a clear process for making decisions.

As I emphasized in the presentation:

“The goal is not simply to get someone through the MMPI. The goal is to put the right person in the armed position.”

— Dr. Justin D’Arienzo

About Dr. Justin D’Arienzo

Dr. Justin D’Arienzo is a board-certified clinical psychologist, former U.S. Navy psychologist, and licensed Texas psychologist whose work includes forensic, occupational, public-safety, and armed-security evaluations.

His ASSIST 2026 presentation drew on experience involving more than 6,000 armed-security psychological evaluations and ongoing examination of security-applicant assessment data. Through D’Arienzo Psychology and PsychFit Systems™, his work emphasizes integrating psychological science with the practical demands of security personnel selection.

He holds licenses in multiple U.S. states and PSYPACT authority. Individual evaluations depend on applicable professional authorization and jurisdictional requirements.

Discuss Your Organization’s Screening Needs

To discuss psychological evaluations, security personnel selection procedures, or a presentation for your organization, contact D’Arienzo Psychology.


Call 904-379-8094


Contact Our Team


Send a Confidential Online Request

Organizations operating internationally are welcome to inquire about their needs and the appropriate scope of services.