Forensic Psychology

INDEPENDENT EVALUATIONS • CIVIL, CRIMINAL & FAMILY LAW

Forensic Psychological Evaluations & Expert Consultation

For attorneys, courts, insurers, and individuals involved in complex legal matters.

D’Arienzo Psychology provides objective psychological assessment, records review, and expert consultation. We address the psychological questions that matter to the case, explain our methods, and communicate findings in a way attorneys and courts can use. Your case is important. Utilizing a competent, experienced, and reputable psychologist is vital.

Jacksonville, Florida  |  (904) 379-8094  |  Interstate services where authorized
ABPP
Board-Certified Clinical Psychology Leadership
20+ Years
Founder’s Clinical & Forensic Experience
PSYPACT
Two Authorized Psychologists
MSCP
Post Doctorate Master’s in Clinical Psychopharmacology
U.S. Navy
Former Navy Operational Psychologist
EXPERIENCED PROFESSIONALS

Meet Our Professional Team

Dr. Justin D'Arienzo

Psy.D., MSCP, ABPP
Forensic, Public Safety & Board-Certified Clinical Psychologist

View Bio

Dr. Michael Nackashi

Psy.D.
Sports, Clinical & Performance Psychologist

View Bio

Dr. Amy Hartley

Ph.D.
Clinical & Forensic Psychologist

View Bio

Dr. Erica Janson

Psy.D.
Clinical & Forensic Psychologist

View Bio

Mario Decunto

LMHC
Licensed Counselor & Life Coach

View Bio

Wendy Monger

Academic Coach
Tutoring Specialist & Academic Coach

View Bio

Services depend on each professional’s training, licensure, and scope of practice.

Forensic assignments are handled by psychologists whose training, experience, and qualifications fit the particular legal question. The team directory above includes professionals whose services are not limited to forensic work.

OUR FORENSIC PSYCHOLOGY SERVICES

Independent Evaluations for Civil, Criminal & Family Law Matters

Forensic psychology requires a different approach from psychotherapy. The task is to answer a defined legal or psycholegal question—not to advocate for a preferred outcome. Depending on the referral, that work may include interviews, psychological testing, record review, collateral information, and written opinions.

Psychological IMEs & Civil Litigation

Independent psychological or compulsory medical examinations (IMEs/CMEs) related to personal injury, emotional distress, disability, trauma, functioning, or disputed psychological damages. We clarify the referral questions, examine available records, administer psychological tests, and evaluate findings within the limits of the evidence.

Social Investigations & Parenting Plans

Evaluations involving parenting arrangements, parental fitness, time-sharing, relocation, and a child’s best interests. We address parental alienation, violence risk, and the psychological needs of the children. Our work considers the information relevant to the court’s questions and applicable law, including Florida social investigations under section 61.20.

Social Investigation Reviews

Sometimes an existing social investigation, custody report, or parenting-plan evaluation is questionable and requires an independent review. We assess the information collected, methods used, reasoning, whether accepted practice guidelines were followed, and whether conclusions are consistent with the documented findings. A review is not automatically a new custody evaluation.

Mitigation & Criminal Defense

Psychological evaluations, testing, and record reviews relevant to sentencing mitigation, life history, trauma, developmental factors, mental health, and other issues raised by defense counsel are analyzed. We identify clinically objective and supportable findings rather than promise a favorable legal result. Additionally, we will meet with your incarcerated individual in most states.

Competency & Sanity Evaluations

Case-specific assessments addressing competence to proceed, adjudicative abilities, mental condition, or criminal responsibility at the time of an alleged offense, where appropriate. The applicable legal standard, court authority, appointment, and evaluator qualifications determine the scope.

Civil & Criminal Case Consultation

Consultation for plaintiff, defense, family-law, and criminal attorneys. Services can include records analysis, review of another expert’s work, identification of psychological issues, expert-witness consultation, and preparing questions for deposition or trial.

Reunification Therapy for Parents and Children

Separation, prolonged parent-child contact problems, and high-conflict divorce can strain family relationships. Reunification therapy uses a structured, child-focused approach to address barriers to contact, improve communication, and work toward safer, healthier family relationships when clinically appropriate. We require a clear court order if the family remains in litigation before therapy begins. Reunification therapy is treatment, not a custody evaluation, and the psychologist’s role is kept separate from making independent forensic opinions. Note that reunification therapy often involves the entire family to be successful.

ADDITIONAL CASE SUPPORT

Expert Testimony, Trial Preparation & Specialized Assessment

Some cases call for a full examination. Others benefit from a focused review of records or a consultation early in discovery. We discuss the scope of the assignment before work begins so counsel knows what the evaluation can—and cannot—answer.

Expert Witness & Deposition Preparation

Independent opinions, deposition and court testimony when appropriate, and assistance in understanding the clinical basis and limitations of psychological evidence.

Trial Preparation for Clients

Help clients understand the demands and stress of testimony, organize concerns, and prepare for the courtroom experience—without scripting testimony or influencing its truthfulness.

Psychosexual & Risk Evaluations

Specialized assessment of psychosexual concerns, relevant risk factors, and psychological functioning when supported by the referral question and evaluator qualifications.

Military & Court-Martial Consultation

Consultation and assessment related to military legal matters, including behavioral health records, mitigation, and clinically relevant questions raised in proceedings.

Disability, Work Capacity & Fitness

Evaluation or consultation involving psychological impairment, work capacity, fitness for duty, and related occupational questions. The legal or administrative standard guides the assignment.

Family-Law Consultation

Parental fitness, custody-related mental health concerns, relocation factors, reunification questions, and review of the docket and family-law psychological evidence.

A PRACTICAL REFERRAL PROCESS

How We Work With Attorneys and Courts

1. Define the question

Tell us the nature of the case, court or jurisdiction, deadline, and the specific psychological issue. We begin with a conflict-of-interest and scope review.

2. Determine the methods

We discuss records, interviews, testing, collateral contacts, and whether remote work is legally and clinically appropriate. Scope and fees are clarified before the work begins.

3. Report findings clearly

As appropriate, we provide written opinions, explain limitations, consult with counsel, or testify. Our conclusions remain independent of which side referred the case.

Forensic evaluations differ from therapy. The referring party and examinee should understand the purpose of the evaluation, who receives the report, and the applicable limits of confidentiality before an examination begins.

INTERSTATE FORENSIC CONSULTATION

PSYPACT Authorization & Interstate Reach

Dr. Justin D’Arienzo and Dr. Amy Hartley hold PSYPACT Authority to Practice Interjurisdictional Telepsychology (APIT). This supports eligible remote psychological services across more than 42 participating states and jurisdictions, including appropriate forensic consultation and assessments when permitted by the receiving jurisdiction.

PSYPACT authorization does not automatically make every forensic evaluation available by video, authorize all court-appointed roles, or grant unrestricted in-person practice in other states. We review the law, court requirements, evaluation method, and case facts before accepting an interstate assignment. Direct state licenses may provide additional options where applicable.

Read more about PSYPACT practice requirements.

COMMON QUESTIONS

Forensic Psychology Services: Frequently Asked Questions

What is a psychological IME?

An independent psychological medical examination or compulsory examination is performed for a defined legal or administrative question. It may involve records, an interview, testing, and a report, depending on the referral and governing requirements.

Can an attorney request a social investigation review without a new evaluation?

Often, yes. A focused records or work-product review can assess methodology, factual support, and the reasoning used in an existing report. We will explain what conclusions can and cannot be reached without independently evaluating the parties.

Do you assist with civil and criminal matters?

Yes. We consider appropriately scoped referrals involving civil litigation, personal injury, family law, mitigation, competency-related questions, case consultation, and expert testimony.

Can forensic services be provided remotely?

Some consultations, record reviews, and evaluations may be possible by secure video. Whether remote work is appropriate depends on the legal jurisdiction, court requirements, test validity, forensic standards, and the particulars of the case.

What should counsel provide when contacting the practice?

Start with the case type, jurisdiction, general referral questions, relevant deadlines, and whether an evaluation or records review is needed. We will arrange a secure way to receive sensitive records after conflicts and scope are reviewed.

CONTACT OUR FORENSIC TEAM

Discuss Your Case Before You Retain an Evaluator

Forensic referrals are most effective when the question is clear at the outset. Contact us to discuss the case type, timeline, location, and services under consideration. We’ll explain the next steps and confirm whether the assignment fits our expertise and availability.

D’Arienzo Psychology  |  Jacksonville, Florida  |  Last Updated: November 2026
Do not include protected, confidential, or privileged case records in an initial unencrypted email. We can arrange a secure method for document exchange.